NEW YORK – This year’s World Economic Forum, more than usual, prompted a spirited round of elite-bashing, which has now become the trendy political posture on both right and left.
On one side, President Trump and Fox News hosts slam the out-of-touch establishment that, according to them, has run things into the ground. On the other side, left-wingers decry the millionaires and billionaires who, in one author’s phrase, “broke the modern world.”
Underlying these critiques is a bleak view of a dysfunctional global order, producing stagnant incomes, rising insecurity and environmental degradation. But is this true?
On the simplest and most important measure, income, the story is one of astonishing progress. Since 1990, more than 1 billion people have moved out of extreme poverty. The share of the global population living in these dire conditions has gone from 36 percent to 10 percent, the lowest in recorded history. This is, as the World Bank president, Jim Yong Kim, notes, “one of the greatest achievements of our time.” Inequality, from a global perspective, has declined dramatically.
And all this has happened chiefly because countries from China to Ethiopia have adopted more market-friendly policies, and Western countries have helped them with access to markets, humanitarian assistance and loan forgivenesss, policies supported by these elites.
The child mortality rate is down 58 percent since 1990. Undernourishment has fallen 41 percent, and maternal deaths (women dying because of childbirth) have dropped by 43 percent over roughly the same period.
I know the response that some will have to these statistics. The figures pertain to the world in general. Things might have improved for the Chinese but not for the denizens of rich countries. That sense of unfairness is what is surely fueling Trump’s America First agenda and much of the anger on the right at the international system. (More bewilderingly, the left, traditionally concerned about the poorest of the poor, has become critical of a process that has improved the lives of a billion of the world’s most impoverished people.)
When criticizing the current state of affairs, it’s easy to hearken back to some nostalgic old order, the modern world before the current elites “broke” it. But when was that golden age? In the 1950s, when Jim Crow reigned in America? The 1980s, when two-thirds of the globe stagnated under state socialism, repression and isolation? What group of elites ran the world better than our current politicians and businessmen?
Even in the West, it is easy to take for granted the astounding progress. We live longer, the air and water are cleaner, crime has plunged and information and communication are virtually free. Economically, there have been gains, though crucially, they have not been distributed equally.
But there have been monumental improvements in access and opportunity for large segments of the population that were locked out and pushed down. In the U.S., the gap between black and white high school completion has almost disappeared. The poverty gap between blacks and whites has shrunk (but remains distressingly large). Hispanic college enrollment has soared. The gender gap between wages for men and women has narrowed. The number of female CEOs at Fortune 500 companies has gone from one to 24 over the last 20 years. Female membership in national legislatures of OECD countries has almost doubled in the same period. No countries allowed gay marriage two decades ago, but more than 20 countries do today. In all these areas, much remains to be done. But in each of them, there has been striking progress.
I understand that important segments of the Western working class are under great pressure, and that they often feel ignored and left behind by this progress. We must find ways to give them greater economic support and moral dignity. But extensive research shows that some of their discomfort comes from watching a society in which these other groups are rising, changing the nature of the world in which they’d enjoyed a comfortable status.
After 400 years of slavery, segregation and discrimination in America, blacks have been moving up. After thousands of years of being treated as structurally subordinate, women are now gaining genuine equality. Once considered criminals or deviants, gays can finally live and love freely in many countries. The fact that these changes might cause discomfort to some is not a reason to pause, nor to forget that it represents deep and lasting human progress that we should celebrate.
Fareed Zakaria is a columnist for The Washington Post.