La Plata County will not downgrade its fire restrictions because weather conditions and fire danger have not changed to justify the move, commissioners said on Thursday.
Commissioners unanimously decided to keep Stage 3 fire restrictions in place.
"It feels to me disingenuous to say a week ago we had a crisis ... and a week later we get an inch of rain and magically that threat isn't there anymore," said Commissioner Julie Westendorff. "And I don't think our community believes it."
The commissioners' action stands directly opposite of those taken by the U.S. Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management and the city of Durango, both of which downgraded fire restrictions on their lands and re-opened the forest, trails and other open spaces Thursday.
Since April, Southwest Colorado has been in an extreme drought, prompting the region to enact various levels of fire restrictions in an effort to prevent wildfire.
In June, fire danger reached a critical level as two active wildfires - the 416 and Burro - burned through the San Juan National Forest.
The dire situation led to the Forest Service closing all 1.8 million acres of the San Juan National Forest. The Bureau of Land Management, the city of Durango and La Plata County also followed suit and closed all public lands to recreation.
The closure was part of enacting Stage 3 fire restrictions, the highest level of restrictions.
The Forest Service, BLM and city said weather this week has tempered fire activity. These agencies also say more resources to fight new fires are now available.
Southwest Colorado received .5 inches to 1.5 inches of rain this past weekend, enough to slow down the active fires but not put them out.
Fire experts for the 416 Fire, however, said by this weekend, all benefits of the rain will be gone and the area will return to high, critical fire danger. The National Weather Service issued a red flag warning for Friday.
"I'm having a really hard time believing the facts that lead to a potential fire getting out of control have changed significantly enough to send a message to the community that it's not as bad today as it was last week," Westendorff said.