RALEIGH, N.C. Soldiers who dont believe in God can go to war with Atheist stamped on their dog tags, but humanists and others with various secular beliefs are still officially invisible in the Army.
Maj. Ray Bradley is applying to be the first humanist recognized as a distinctive faith group leader by the Army. In the meantime, he cant be designated as a humanist on his official records or dog tags, although he can be classified as an atheist.
The distinction may not seem like a large one to those unfamiliar with humanism, but the Fort Bragg-based officer says its the equivalent of being told that Christian is an acceptable designation, but not Catholic.
Humanism is a philosophy that guides a person, Bradley said. Its more than just a stamp of what youre not.
Humanisms core beliefs range from the assertion that knowledge of the world is derived from observation and rational analysis to the conviction that working to help others also promotes individual happiness.
The issue is another sign of the growing willingness of military personnel at Fort Bragg and other military bases to publicly identify themselves as atheists, agnostics, humanists or otherwise without belief in a supernatural higher power and seek the same recognition granted to Christians, Jews and other believers.
There are a lot more people with these beliefs than just Major Ray Bradley, but hes in a position where he can stand up and put in a request for this, said Jason Torpy, president of the Military Association of Atheists and Freethinkers and an Army veteran.
Bradley, a veteran of the war in Afghanistan who enlisted in 1986, is respectful and protective of the Army, and careful to say his views are his own.
He said he has been a humanist since before he enlisted, when No Religious Preference was his only option. Now he feels getting his official records to match his convictions is an important symbolic point.
Theres no regulation that says I cant go downtown and get a set of tags made that say humanist, but I wont do that because it wont be on my official record, he said. To me, this is an individual right.
A petition campaign organized by Torpys group wants humanist and spiritual but not religious added to the currently available religious designations.
Bradley said he applied for the change to his record after learning that atheist was now an officially recognized choice for soldiers. His request was ultimately rejected by the Army Chaplain Corps, he said, which didnt respond to a request for comment. Bradley believes some of the resistance comes from a lack of familiarity with humanism.
I dont think the chaplaincy really understands the difference between atheism and humanism, he said.
Humanism goes beyond a simple statement of disbelief in the existence of a deity or deities, said Howard Katz, president of the Humanist Society, which is sponsoring Bradleys application to become a lay humanist leader at Bragg.
Atheism means just that: You dont believe in God, Katz said. You could have an ax murderer whos an atheist. Humanists have ethics and a philosophy.
They also have formal life-cycle celebrations for occasions like marriages, funerals, even what Katz calls humanist bar mitzvahs. Founded in 1939 and chartered as a religious organization, the Humanist Society also certifies celebrants to perform the ceremonies, who then have the same legal authority as members of the clergy.
It shouldnt be a surprise that humanists and other non theists in the military are becoming more vocal, because their civilian counterparts are doing the same thing, said Penny Edgell, a sociologist at the University of Minnesota who studies American religion.
There are lots more organizations for atheists, agnostics and humanists now than there used to be, she said. This is an emerging identity.
The organization of non-theists parallels the mobilization of conservative religious believers in American society, Edgell said. As one group asserts its identity, the other feels the need to respond.
People are aware that if youre going to claim it, you have to claim it more strongly, she said. Theres kind of a cycle of mobilization.
The Army currently has no humanist chaplains or laypersons authorized to perform limited chaplain duties, a position roughly equivalent to a deacon or elder in a Christian church.
A soldier at Fort Meade, Md., has also filed the paperwork seeking the designation, which is a more formal process in the Army and Navy than in the Air Force, where a humanist lay leader is stationed at MacDill Air Force Base, Fla., according to Torpy.
Bradley sees his role as essentially organizing the humanists at Fort Bragg and securing a regular meeting place, for listening to speakers or just gather to talk about their experiences.
I dont want to make it sound too religious, he said with a laugh, after catching himself using the word congregation.
A minority is always much bigger than whats visible on the surface until theyre accepted by society, he said. Once people realize that their neighbors are part of this minority, and theyre just regular people like anyone else, they become accepted.
Thats important if non-theists continue to grow in the larger society, said David Segal, director of the Center for Research on Military Organization at the University of Maryland. Surveys vary, but between 15 and 20 percent of Americans now dont identify with any particular religion, although not all of those people are non-theists.
There is that trend in society, and we strive to have our military as representative of our society as possible, he said. Thats part of the reason the right to serve became so important for blacks, and then women, and then gays. Youve got that added dimension of military service being a hallmark of citizenship.