NEW YORK How can a cancer come back after its apparently been eradicated? Three new studies are bolstering a long-debated idea: that tumors contain their own pool of stem cells that can multiply and keep fueling the cancer, seeding regrowth.
If thats true, scientists will need to find a way to kill those cells, apart from how they attack the rest of the tumor.
Stem cells in healthy tissues are known for their ability to produce any kind of cell. The new research deals with a different kind, cancer stem cells. Some researchers, but not all, believe they lurk as a persisting feature in tumors.
During the last decade, studies have found evidence for them in tumors such as breast and colon cancers. But this research has largely depended on transplanting human cancer cells into mice that dont have immune systems, an artificial environment that raises questions about the relevance of the results.
Now, three studies reported online Wednesday in the journals Nature and Science present evidence for cancer stem cells within the original tumors. Again, the research relies on mice. That and other factors mean the new findings still wont convince everyone that cancer stem cells are key to finding more powerful treatments.
But researcher Luis Parada, of the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas, believes his team is onto something. He said for the type of brain tumor his team studied, weve identified the true enemy.
If his finding applies to other cancers, he said, then even if chemotherapy drastically shrinks a tumor but doesnt affect its supply of cancer stem cells, very little progress has actually been made.
The three studies used labeling techniques to trace the ancestry of cells within mouse tumors.
Collectively, they give very strong support to the cancer stem-cell theory, said Jeffrey M. Rosen, a professor of molecular and cellular biology at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston. He did not participate in the work but supports the theory, which he said is widely accepted.
Another scientist whos skeptical about the theory, and said he has plenty of company, said the new papers did not change his mind.
Paradas team worked with mice genetically primed to develop a certain type of brain tumor. The scientists genetically labeled particular cells in the tumor and then attacked the cancer with the same drug given to human patients.
It kills growing tumor cells and temporarily stops the cancers growth. After treatment, when the tumor started growing again in the mice, the researchers showed that the vast majority, if not all, of its new cells had descended from the labeled cells. Apparently, these were the tumors cancer stem cells, they concluded.
Parada said his team is now trying to isolate cancer stem cells from mouse brain cancers to study them and perhaps get some leads for developing therapies to eradicate them.
He also said preliminary study of human brain tumors is producing results consistent with what his team found in the mice.
Paradas study appears in Nature. In a second Nature report, British and Belgian researchers found evidence for cancer stem cells in early stage skin tumors in mice. And in the journal Science, a Dutch group found such evidence in mouse intestinal polyps, which are precursors to colon cancer.
Scott Kern of the Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore is skeptical about whether tumors contain cancer stem cells. He said because the new studies didnt involve human tumors, its not clear how relevant they are to people.
The two European studies focused largely on lesions that can lead to tumors, he said. And, as for Paradas brain cancer study, he said, he believed the results could be explained without relying on the cancer stem cell theory.