SALEM, Ore. Wet winters and cool, dry summers make Oregons Willamette Valley one of the best places on the planet to produce seeds for organic broccoli, cabbage, cauliflower, Brussels sprouts and a variety of other vegetables known as brassicas.
That means the fields south of Portland also are an ideal place to grow canola, another brassica whose seeds can be pressed to extract oil for food or renewable fuel.
But you wont find any canola here. It was banned from the Willamette Valley to protect the delicate vegetable seeds from being contaminated by pollen from canola or destroyed by the pests and diseases it brings.
Demand for renewable energy, however, has helped fuel a push to grow canola in the region, raising a tense conflict between producers of organic foods and renewable energy in a state that cherishes both.
Seed farmers fear canola would cross-pollinate with their plants, destroying the value of the pure seeds they produce. Theyre joined in their fight by organic-food lovers, small-farm advocates and opponents of genetically modified crops.
This is an existential threat, said Frank Morton, who farms about 12 acres of specialty seeds in Philomath, about 90 miles southwest of Portland. If canola comes here, its the beginning of the end of this industry.
Canola proponents say Morton and his colleagues are overreacting. With the right controls, they argue, Canola can coexist without harming other brassicas. Some wheat and grass-seed farmers are eager to use canola as a rotational crop to interrupt disease and pest cycles. They used to burn their fields at the end of the season, but recent pollution controls have severely limited that option.
It comes down to good stewardship and cooperating with your neighbors and good management practices, said Kathy Hadley, who grows grass seed and other crops in the Salem area. Everyone does those things on a regular basis already, and I feel like, in this specific case, things are being blown out of proportion.
The state Department of Agriculture has proposed loosening the ban on growing canola in the Willamette Valley, reducing the exclusion zone from 3.7 million acres to 1.7 million, with some restrictions. After public hearings, the agency director is expected to make a final decision by the end of the year.
They can grow this stuff anywhere else, said George Kimbrell, a lawyer from the Center for Food Safety representing specialty seed farmers. Its just this one area thats being protected for many very good reasons. Its not like Oregon or anywhere else is saying you cant grow your canola. Its one area.
Specialty seed farmers grow vegetables not for the food but for their seeds. Theyre shipped to farmers around the world, especially in Asia and Europe where theres higher demand for foods that arent genetically modified. This region produces nearly all of the worlds European cabbage, Brussels sprouts, rutabaga and turnip seeds, according to a 2010 study by Oregon State University.
Canola, by contrast, is uncommon in Oregon, where farmers planted just 6,500 acres of it this year, most of it in Eastern Oregon, across a mountain range from the brassica seed fields.
Seed farmers here describe the expansion of canola as a Pandoras Box that, once opened, will destroy their industry.
Wind can carry pollen up to five miles. Seed farmers worry that genetically modified canola plants will pollinate with organic brassicas, producing seeds with no value. Theyre especially concerned that canola would become a weed that takes root far and wide, producing pollen even inside the canola-free zone.
They also worry about cabbage maggots and white mold, a fungus that can destroy root vegetable crops.
Given those risks, the 2010 Oregon State study concluded that precaution suggests not allowing canola production at this time. Those concerns havent changed, said professor Russ Karow, the studys author.
Concerns about cross-pollination can be mitigated with a system to track the location of various crops, he said, but theres no way to know how widespread pests and diseases would be with large-scale canola fields.
People keep asking, Is there a scientific answer? Karow said, and there is not.