PITTSBURGH In the Colorado mountains, a spike in air pollution has been linked to a boom in gas-and-oil drilling. About 800 miles away on the plains of north Texas, theres a drilling boom, too, but some air-pollution levels have declined. Opponents of drilling point to Colorado and say its dangerous. Companies point to Texas and say drilling is safe.
The answer appears to be that drilling can be safe or it can be dangerous. Industry practices, enforcement, geography and even snow cover can minimize or magnify air-pollution problems.
Its like a vehicle. Some cars drip oil, said Russell Schnell, deputy director of the federal Earth System Research Laboratory in Boulder. You have wells that are absolutely tight. And you have other places where a valve gives out, and you have huge leaks.
The good news, nearly all sides agree, is that the technology exists to control methane leaks and other air pollution associated with drilling. The bad news is that the industry is booming so rapidly that some companies and some regulators cant seem to get ahead of the problems, which could ultimately cost billions of dollars to remedy.
The worries about what drilling does to the air are global and local, with scientists concerned about the effects on climate change as well as the possible health consequences from breathing smog, soot and other pollutants.
Hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, has made it possible to tap into deep reserves of gas and oil but has also raised concerns about pollution. The industry and many federal and state officials say the practice is safe when done properly, but environmental groups and some scientists say there hasnt been enough research.
Some environmentalists say if leaks and pollution can be minimized, the boom has benefits, since gas burns much cleaner than coal, emitting half the carbon dioxide.
Al Gore told The Associated Press that its not irresponsible to look at gas as a short-term substitute for coal-fired electricity. But Gore said that the main component of gas, methane, is a more potent heat-trapping greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide. That means that if large quantities leak, the advantage over coal disappears, the former vice president said.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration estimates that 4 percent of methane is leaking from wells. That is far more than previously estimated, and that people who live near production areas may be exposed to worrisome levels of benzene and other toxic compounds present in gas and oil.
Across the industry, the technology for stopping leaks can be as simple as fixing seals and gaskets, or it can involve hundreds of millions of dollars of new construction.
I think its totally fixable, Schnell said. At least the bigger companies, they are really on top of this.